Snark Weighs In

Carolyn Hinsey Fired?

posted Thursday, 7 August 2008

It appears that Carolyn Hinsey has been fired from her job as Editor-in-Chief of Soap Opera Weekly.  On a side note, comment no. 45 in that link might be the funniest thing I've ever read.

There's discussion over at SON, as well.

PREVIOUS HINSEY COVERAGE

July 29, 2007: Hypocritical Hinsey Blasts Soapnet

October 4, 2007: Hinsey on Jax's Rape.

November 30, 2007: Striking Soap Writers Blast Hinsey

(Update, 8/8/08): Nelson Branco reports in his column today that he's spoken with an insider at Interlink Media, which owns SOD and SOW.  According to said insider, who names budget cuts a a factor for Hinsey's exit, "It's a mutual decision.  Carolyn's not upset.  She has other irons in the fire."  Right.  And Dan Rather really wanted to leave the CBS Evening News, and do stories for 60 Minutes every three months.

Meanwhile, the Jossip thread that started all this has gotten so insane, that there's a second Jossip thread devoted to highlights from the comments section of the first.  Apparently, all the Munchkins from Munchkinland came out to celebrate last night. 

On the one hand, you wonder about anonymous threads and how much can really be true; on the other, some of this stuff is so outrageous, it does seem to fall under the heading of "you can't make this up."  Writing about attending soap star functions at an NYC bar, without revealing that you own the bar?  Stealing story ideas and bylines?   Being obsessed with Randolph Mantooth?  Flashing your checkbook, just so everybody can see how much you make?

It also appears that Stephanie Sloane and Lynn Leahey join Hinsey in being less popular than syphillis.  What is with this industry?  From top to bottom, everybody in soaps today appears to be evil, insane, or insanely evil.




1. Indydavid left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 5:26 pm

I could care less if she was fired or not....I don't particularly like her although sometimes her columns could be quite snarky and funny.


2. Chris left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 5:35 pm

LOL! Love the pic!

Good riddance Carolyn! A soap fan you were. A constructive, insightful, intelligent journalist you were not. It's only my opinion.


3. Adam left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 5:37 pm

Carolyn Hinsey should have been fired. She has ruined Soap Opera Weekly which used to have so many more good features besides spoilers for the following week or synopsis, which are all of 4 sentences long for each soap, comings and goings and not enough scoop. Most of the stuff they print has already been announced online. Sometimes, they get something that is exclusive to them but rarely. I have always heard that she had a bad reputation as being a control-freak, devil wears Prada kind of boss plus I just think she hasn't kept up with the demands of the fans - more behind the scenes news PLEASE. I want to know who is producing, writing AND acting on my soaps. SOW has been diminishing ever since the incredible Mimi Torchin left. I remember when Soap Opera Digest would have 5 page summaries of the past 2 weeks of each show. Luckily I am a pack rat so i have 2 boxes filled with issues of SOD dating back to 1984. The covers were amazing and actually posed for and planned and edited by the magazine. Plus, they weren't random stories, they all had to do with whatever was the hottest storyline for the following week. They would have covers with 5 or more actors. Once OLTL had a murder mystery and they had all the suspects on the cover looking suspicious. I treasure those magazines because I can always take one and read it from cover to cover and relive some of my favorite storylines from the shows. Anyway, i do not think this will go down in the history books for publishing. Carolyn Hinsley was a nobody in the real world of magazines and she never earned the respect that she acted like she deserved. She has not done anything original or fun or sexy with the magazine ever. What happened to creativity? I can't think it is because of budget cuts because I have not heard that SOW is folding so why would they change editors now. because the current one stinks is why. They need fresh blood over there, a younger soap fans with ideas of taking soap journalism into the future. I nominate Nelson Branco.


4. Indydavid left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 5:52 pm

Please...anyone but Nelson Branco...while the guy is good at snagging interviews with some of the stars, he just regurgitates what's in SOD while adding his own lavicious comments about the male soap stars and stroking his own ego.


5. GuillermoIbarra left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 8:06 pm

I think if Hinsey has indeed been fired, it's #1 of a 1-2 punch. #2 will be SOW and SOD merging.

And, oh god no no no, please no to Branco as her replacement. That would be like complaining Maury Povich is too tabloidy and then replacing him with Jerry Springer.


6. Cecile DeP. left...
Thursday, 7 August 2008 11:31 pm

I liked Jossip comment no. 62 myself...


7. DS0816 left...
Friday, 8 August 2008 1:26 pm

How much life is left in "Soap Opera Digest" and "Soap Opera Weekly"?

If it wasn't Hinsey, it would've been someone else in her position. I think it's a financial thing No. 1. As for the quality of Hinsey's work, I really didn't keep up. I know of last year's controversial stuff (especially in April, when she offered up her "Come to Jesus" moment designed to give readers/soap viewers a "reality check"; stuff that Snark and Brian discussed on "Snarkcast").

All in all, this is just another news item that, in the world of today's depleted daytime dramas, doesn't matter.

Thanks for the report, Snark!


8. Nicole left...
Friday, 8 August 2008 4:10 pm

She should have gotten fired over the Jax rape comments last year, if you ask me.


9. GuillermoIbarra left...
Saturday, 9 August 2008 9:03 am

Carolyn owns Blondie's? I didn't know that. Somehow I missed that.


10. Byron left...
Sunday, 10 August 2008 5:33 pm

WOW! Seems these three have manipulated the whole genre to their advantage and it has now bitten them right on the butt. Hope they have great lawyers and a lot of money saved.